MUDRA LOAN SCHEME: A CRITICAL ANALYSISMarch 16, 2019
Micro Finance is an economic development tool whose objective is to assist the poor to work their way out of poverty. It covers a range of services which include, in addition to the provision of credit, many other services such as savings, insurance, money transfers, counseling etc. The players in the Micro Finance sector can be qualified as falling into 3 main groups: – the SHG-Bank linkage model started by NABARD, the Non-Banking Finance companies and the others including Trusts, Societies etc.
The government set up a Micro Units Development and Refinance Agency (MUDRA) Bank which would be responsible for regulating and refinancing all Micro-finance Institutions (MFI) which are in the business of lending to micro/small business entities engaged in manufacturing, trading and services activities.
MUDRA scheme is aimed at “funding the unfunded”. The small entrepreneurs of India are used to exploitation at the hands of money lenders so far, but MUDRA will instill new confidence in them that the country is ready to support them in their efforts that are contributing so heavily to the task of nation-building.
· The primary product of MUDRA will be refinanced for lending to micro businesses/units under the aegis of the Pradhan Mantri MUDRA Yojana.
· MUDRA Bank has been established by the government with a Refinance corpus of Rs.20, 000 crore, and credit guarantee corpus of Rs.3000 crore.
It is to be noted that at least 60% of loans shall be disbursed under Shishu category and remaining for Kishor and Tarun categories.
· All commercial banks (Private or Public), RRB, Cooperative Bank or other Micro Finance Institutions are eligible for refinance under PM Mudra Yojana.
· Collateral Security: Banks have been mandated not to insist for collateral security in the case of loans up to 10 Lakh extended to the units in the Micro Small Enterprises sector.
The idea of connecting every last mile financer to lending credit to all type of business is not particular to India. To reach every common person is beyond imagination for Banks and only MFIs or local money lender can do this to flow credit to every needed person.
Whenever informal sector people like rickshaw pullers, household factories etc., look for formal credit then condition of security was a major hurdle in getting loan and can’t be fulfilled as these people do not own any property. As now in Mudra loan, there is no condition of collateral up to a loan of Rs 10 Lakh and it will help to fund the unfunded.
It has various dynamic features like Mudra Card, Bank Limit etc. which make the scheme more attractive. In Bank Limit, amount sanctioned for a loan shall be deposited into one’s Mudra account and then one can get credit any time from use of Mudra Card. The interest will be subjected to the amount and time period that one has used but not on the whole amount for the whole of the year.
As the majority of loan amount i.e. 60% shall be allotted to Shishu category can be very useful for extreme poor population included SC/STs, a majority of sole proprietor business in home-based processing units, such as pickles, papad is run by them.
There is no doubt that growth of the informal sector has more effect on every macroeconomic variable like GDP, Per capita income, gross capital formation or employment generation etc. because this sector already employs more than 12 Cr population in approx 5 Cr enterprises.
Many put question of creating a new refinance agency Mudra as we already have another agency to refinance for purpose of business only like National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (NABARD) and the Small Industries Development Bank of India (SIDBI).
The world is already in a path to discourage shadow banking (like refinancing agencies etc) and to replace it with mainline banking as far as possible. That’s why RBI has set up small financial banks and MFIs get a chance to shift to banking. It does not make much sense to establish a new refinance agency as it will not solve the purpose, but simply cause of tussle between many agencies and regulators.
The poor grievance redressal is one of major problem where government scheme ends to a failure or without success. The government has created new schemes and institutions for a special focus on micro business by passing the existing mechanism or institutions but remains to depend on the same mechanism of grievance redressal which is universally poor in India.
The idea of connecting last mile financiers might only be limited to Banks or some big NBFCs because to register with MUDRA, financiers have to pass a litmus test of a number of bureaucratic documents and further need to comply with RBI guidelines which may not be feasible for most of the small financiers.
It is also said that Banks and MFIs are converting previous loans into MUDRA and that’s why the government is able to show large numbers of loans have already been given.
The NPA level, which is already a big problem, might grow at an unexpected level due to this type of easy loan to everyone.
As government banks provide financial services to more than 70% population of India, the bureaucratic nature of government employees is among major hurdles in implementation of Mudra scheme.
However NPA might get a boost is just an apprehension by banks or people as a track record of credit given to Self Help Groups (SHGs) makes it clear that poor are more honest than the likes of corporate leaders such as, Vijay Malya or Subrata Roy, who have defaulted billions of dollars. Also, it might be better to have NPAs of billion dollars by Lakhs of people than by only one or two people.
The only thing Banks or RBI has to do is to create a single platform to check past record of the person applying for a loan and if never defaulted then provide the loan to person as fast as possible.
Overall, MUDRA is a step in the right direction for funding the unfunded but government shall set up robust monitoring and grievance redressal mechanism to take cognizance problems arrived under the scheme.